Skip to content

Report: Failure to repair throttle led to Indonesia aircraft crash


JAKARTA, Indonesia — Indonesian aviation investigators concluded Thursday {that a} almost decade-long failure to correctly restore a malfunctioning automated throttle, pilots’ overreliance on the aircraft’s automation system, and insufficient coaching contributed to the crash of a Boeing 737-500 final 12 months that killed 62 folks.

Nationwide Transportation Security Committee investigators mentioned of their ultimate report that the Sriwijaya Air jet’s upkeep report confirmed the issue with the automated throttle had been reported by pilots 65 instances since 2013 and was nonetheless unsolved when the 26-year-old aircraft plunged into the Java Sea after taking off from Jakarta on Jan. 9, 2021.

Lead investigator Nurcahyo Utomo mentioned at a information convention that the pilots’ final dialog with air visitors management was about 4 minutes after takeoff, after they responded to an instruction to go as much as 13,000 ft. The aircraft’s flight knowledge recorder confirmed it reached an altitude of 10,900 ft after which started declining, Utomo mentioned.

He mentioned the aircraft required much less engine thrust because it neared its goal altitude, however that the automated throttle was unable to cut back the proper engine’s energy due to friction within the mechanical system.

The automated throttle tried to compensate by decreasing the left engine’s energy additional, reducing its output to as little as 34%. The best engine’s energy remained at its climb setting, or about 92%, leading to sharply unequal thrust, the report mentioned.

The pilot fought to carry the aircraft up, however “was unable to recuperate from the state of affairs,” and the jet rolled onto its left facet, the report mentioned.

A minute later, the flight knowledge recorder confirmed that the automated throttle had been disengaged because the aircraft pitched down. The recorder stopped recording a number of seconds later.

The automated throttle can be utilized by pilots to set the pace mechanically, thereby decreasing their workload and put on on the engines. Actions of the automated throttle are linked to 13 different elements of the aircraft, the report mentioned.

Lots of the issues resulting in the crash have been disclosed in a preliminary report issued by Indonesian authorities final 12 months. The ultimate report launched Thursday supplied new particulars of the pilots’ response to them.

Utomo mentioned insufficient coaching “contributed to the lack of the pilot to forestall and recuperate from the situation.”

The pilots’ overreliance on the aircraft’s automation system might have resulted in insufficient monitoring within the cockpit, in order that the flight deviation was not instantly seen, the report mentioned.

Utomo mentioned the voice knowledge recorder solely labored on one audio channel, and one other channel that was alleged to report all voices within the cockpit was stuffed with an unknown buzzing sound that prevented investigators from totally analyzing the coordination between the 2 pilots.

The report concluded that repeated makes an attempt to restore the automated throttle through the years had failed as a result of that they had not correctly fastened the mechanical problem.

Investigators labored with Boeing and engine maker Normal Electrical to evaluate info from the flight knowledge recorder. A crew from the US Nationwide Transportation Security Board and Federal Aviation Administration additionally joined the investigation.

The aircraft had been out of service for nearly 9 months due to flight cutbacks attributable to the coronavirus pandemic. Regulators and the airline mentioned it underwent inspections earlier than resuming business flights in December 2020.

The catastrophe reignited considerations about security in Indonesia’s aviation business, which expanded rapidly after the nation’s financial system was opened up following the autumn of dictator Suharto within the late Nineties. The US banned Indonesian airways from working there in 2007 however lifted the measure in 2016, citing enhancements in compliance with worldwide aviation requirements. The European Union lifted an identical ban in 2018.

Sriwijaya Air, an Indonesian home airline based in 2003, has had solely minor security incidents previously, although a farmer was killed in 2008 when a aircraft went off the runway whereas touchdown resulting from a hydraulic problem.

In 2018, a Boeing 737 MAX 8 jet operated by Indonesia’s Lion Air crashed, killing 189 folks. An automatic flight management system performed a job in that crash, however the Sriwijaya Air jet didn’t have that system on board.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *