Skip to content

New cap creates “point-in-time freeze” on Maui TVRs; begins regulation on camper vans : Maui Now

PC: Wendy Osher

Cap retains variety of TVRs on Maui “establishment”

In an ongoing effort to handle tourism, the Maui County Council handed Invoice 159 Friday with a collection of amendments that successfully cap transient lodging and regulate camper van leases on public property. The invoice was handed in an 8-0 vote on second and ultimate studying, with Councilmember Kelly King excused.

The invoice was drafted to create a “point-in-time freeze” on all presently allowed brief time period rental makes use of, and “a lot wanted regulation” on the camper van rental trade, in response to backers.

“The latest robust push for tangible administration initiatives is a brand new part, and with something new, there are rising pains,” stated Vice Chair Keani Rawlins-Fernandez, who launched the invoice. Expressing bittersweet sentiment, she defined the present invoice was amended down considerably.

“Whereas what I’d have needed–requiring all lodging to be capped, and extra council oversight by way of conditional permits, which requires council approval–this has been amended down… This invoice remains to be wonderful and I am grateful to all of the folks that labored so exhausting on it for nearly two years now.”

–Keani Rawlins-Fernandez, Council Vice-Chair

Transient Trip Leases, as outlined by the County of Maui are any rental of a housing unit for lower than 180 days. The Maui County Code Chapter 19.37 prohibits transient trip leases exterior of the resort district, however there’s a conditional allow course of for operations exterior of the district. They differ from Mattress and Breakfast operations, that are allowed in enterprise and residential districts with a allow. The county estimates that there are 16,000-plus TVRs that will legally function in Maui County.


The proposed caps are meant to maintain the variety of transient lodging “establishment,” stated Rawlins-Fernandez. She defined that if an proprietor was working or had the choice to function on the date of the invoice’s passage, that use can be allowed to proceed; however after adoption, no different progress or improve would happen.

“This method was taken after the recommendation of authorized counsel to keep away from any potential authorized challenges from property house owners that will declare takings which might be very pricey to taxpayers,” stated Rawlins-Fernandez.

The council recognized zoning districts that presently enable Quick Time period Leases, and created a cap for every district, together with the Lahaina Historic District 1 and a pair of, House district, Enterprise Nation City, Enterprise District 2 and three, Enterprise Resort, Deliberate Growth, Resort, and Timeshare.

However even with the council’s efforts in “pouring by way of the code,” and the six months of labor invested by the Tourism Administration and Financial Growth Short-term Investigative Group, member Tamara Paltin stated there have been areas like Undertaking District that have been unintentionally missed. She stated the passage of the invoice didn’t mark an finish of the dialogue.

Rawlins-Fernandez stated choices made by earlier council majorities “signaled computerized assist of additional unfettered growth and new improvement.”


Paltin stated that when choices have been made to assist tourism, resort growth, and advertising and marketing Maui, “there was not a plan of the whole imaginative and prescient or when to cease, or when to have the stability.”

“When there is no plan to manage, handle and malama that stability, it turns right into a nightmare.”

–Tamara Paltin, Councilmember – West Maui

“I agree this is not every thing–all that we’d have needed–but it surely’s a step within the second time period and what we actually must do, [to] proceed dialogue not solely of administration, however of diversification, of different sorts of administration, of utilizing the Maui County TAT (Transient Lodging Tax) to spend money on the infrastructure to offset and mitigate the impacts. So I imply, actually that is one other step at first of the dialogue. It is undoubtedly not the tip of the dialogue, and it isn’t the one solution to handle tourism,” stated Paltin.

Camper van language revised, permits to be used in permitted zones

Included within the invoice is a chapter that prohibits short-term parking of camper vans, leisure automobiles and trailers or comparable equipment used for transient lodging, except the exercise is allowed by a zoning allow.

An modification was made to incorporate automobiles with pop-up tents, and language was added to permit for the exercise in areas the place it’s particularly permitted.


The revisions have been made after a number of enterprise house owners who function camper van rental firms on Maui testified in opposition to the invoice saying it was “ambiguous” and contradictory to different provisions of the Maui County Code.

Previous to the modification approval, an legal professional representing Zazu Campers LLC and an alliance of firms working leisure rental automobiles companies on Maui, stated the county doesn’t have the authority to utterly ban a selected kind of auto, and argued that rental automobiles are regulated by state, not county legislation.

Members of a newly shaped alliance consisting of eight rental firms on Maui, stated the mixed companies function roughly 65 automobiles between them, and questioned the general affect this provision would have on tourism administration.

Fearing the unique model of the invoice would strip him and others like him of their livelihoods, Sean, the proprietor of Epic Maui Leases LLC, stated, “This would possibly not make a dent within the root subject that the invoice goals to deal with. It will not take away illegally parked automobiles on the aspect of the highway; It will not take away unlawful encampments on the seashore; It will not shield the land or reduce over tourism. There are presently 741 registered homeless individuals on this island and at the very least 15,000 individuals staying at motels and resorts on any given day.”

“All this invoice will do is shut down our companies and ship our 200 company to massive business automotive rental firms with no steering or info, after which most likely to Walmart to purchase low cost tents and disposable tenting gear… I consider in my coronary heart that shutting us down.” down shouldn’t be the answer.”

–Sean, proprietor of Epic Maui Leases LLC

The council finally heard the argument and amended the invoice to supply higher readability on the particular “on the bottom” affect to the camper van trade.

“It signifies that they will nonetheless do the exercise the place it’s particularly permitted, stated Paltin, noting that there are permitted areas at Nationwide Parks and Camp Olowalu the place there are services for such exercise.

“So the place it is particularly allowed, then it may be accomplished in these particular areas. Roadsides, individuals’s neighborhoods the place they do not need individuals going to the lavatory within the bushes–No can… You may’t simply go into Haleakalā Park within the parking zone. It’s a must to be within the permitted space.”

–Tamara Paltin, Councilmember – West Maui

Paltin stated that if the automobiles keep in designated areas which have the assets to accommodate them, and there is nonetheless room for residents to take pleasure in tenting as nicely, “it isn’t a horrible factor.”

Division of the Company Counsel’s Michael J. Hopper stated the pop-up tents language added readability and was in step with the intent of the prohibition. There was additionally language added–“except particularly permitted”–which offers with circumstances the place camper van parking is likely to be permitted, whether or not or not it’s in a state park or in a spot the place the County points a allow to be used.

“I do consider that that is throughout the county’s purview. HRS does enable the County some authority to manage the usage of automobiles for human habitation, so I believe that is in step with that,” he stated.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *