Skip to content

How BC communities are tackling short-term leases

More and more, officers are making the choice to place locals’ housing first—can Whistler comply with go well with?

Ace short-term trip rental platforms like Airbnb and VRBO have taken off and utterly reshaped the tourism lodging panorama, locations from Vancouver to Venice have grappled with methods to stability the housing wants of everlasting residents towards the financial boon that second owners and the vacationers they serve deliver.

In BC, tourism hotspots have taken decidedly totally different approaches in relation to regulating short-term leases, however, more and more, officers are realizing the identical factor: the necessity to put locals’ housing first.

“These are folks which are staffing all these tourism amenities and these [short-term rentals could be] houses for the nurses, the RCMP officers, the restaurant employees, the grocery retailer employees. These are those that run our group they usually haven’t got houses right here,” mentioned Lesley-Anne Staats, director of planning for the City of Gibsons.

It is a chorus that ought to be acquainted to Whistlerites, the place, in response to the 2016 census, 61 per cent of privately owned dwellings sit empty or are at the very least quickly occupied for a superb chunk of the 12 months. More moderen figures from a 2021 housing survey confirmed that simply 10 per cent of all market residential properties are rented on a long-term foundation to locals. (Notably, greater than 75 per cent of all secondary suites on the town are rented to residents.)

It is tough to gauge precisely how the proliferation of short-term rental platforms has impacted Whistler’s rental market, however there isn’t any denying the monetary attract nightly leases current to second owners, typically saddled with pricey mortgages and trying to get a good return on their funding. That bore out in Airbnb’s personal knowledge, which, earlier this 12 months, ranked Whistler as Canada’s most worthwhile group for hosts renting out their items for so-called “long-term” stays, outlined as 28 days or longer.

Though short-term leases are actually not the one contributing issue, we additionally know that the variety of out there rental houses in the neighborhood has largely remained stagnant since 2006 “regardless that the group inhabitants has grown considerably throughout that point,” in response to this 12 months’s provincially mandated housing wants report, offered to council in Might.

Then there’s the relative comfort of renting a property out to guests for a handful of days a 12 months versus renting long-term to locals and all of the related tasks—and complications—that may include that.

The identical provincial housing report additionally took be aware of “opportunists who search to make use of residential houses as unlawful nightly leases which the municipality continues to implement towards.” Solely neighborhoods with particular tourist-accommodation or temporary-accommodation zoning are permitted to host nightly leases, and house owners who want to market their property for short-term stays should first receive a enterprise license from the municipality, whether or not rental exercise has taken place or not .

Following the streams in Gibsons

Within the coastal enclave of Gibsons, officers spent the previous two years growing their regulatory framework for short-term leases, finally touchdown on an method that divides residential visitor lodging into two separate streams: one for dwelling items with a principal resident, and one for items the place nobody completely resides.

“The primary stream is principally a conventional B&B the place you, as an example, lease out the 2 bedrooms in your house (one for principal residents, and one for visitors],” mentioned City of Gibsons planning director Lesley-Anne Staats. is each house is a house for a resident of Gibsons.”

Below the second stream, operators with no principal resident should receive considered one of a restricted variety of temporary-use permits (TUP) to lease out their property, with plans for that class to be phased out totally throughout the subsequent two to 5 years.

“The secondary stream is a inventive approach to enable one thing that is not allowed. So, proper now, the best way we have written our zoning rules is we have mentioned, ‘You are not allowed to lease out a complete house as visitor lodging,’ however we’re utilizing a instrument within the Native Authorities Act, which is a temporary-use allow, and that permits you to do one thing for a short lived time period that is not allowed in zoning,” Staats defined.

That technique was arrived at by means of a lot debate in the neighborhood, Staats mentioned, noting that the discussions have been typically fraught, significantly from operators and second owners from the Decrease Mainland who out of the blue noticed their funding properties lose a lot of their inherent worth.

“We went to public listening to and numerous the operators complained about it, regardless that it was fairly huge open at the moment for operators to host any such lodging. After which council handed a decision to make the principles much more relaxed, not likely recognizing the impacts that may have on housing,” Staats mentioned.

Because the city watched its long-term residents get squeezed out of attainable housing and native retailers and eating places have been compelled to slash hours attributable to employees shortages (sound acquainted?), officers went again to the drafting board.

“So what we needed to do at that time was… return to the very starting and speak about our targets—and we needed to reset these targets. At the moment, [council] unanimously supported retaining the long-term rental provide in Gibsons as the first aim,” recounted Staats. “There was numerous pressure in that dialogue as a result of numerous councilors needed to assist tourism as nicely, whereas additionally realizing you may’t draft these suggestions permitting each equally. We had to decide on a route, and so folks ended up selecting retaining the long-term rental provide, and by doing that, we hold housing because the No. 1 precedence.”

The TUP system additionally permits Gibsons to maintain higher tabs on secondary properties used for visitor lodging.

“We have not outlawed short-term leases or any such visitor lodging. We’re simply ensuring that each house is on the market to any person. And if it isn’t, then we’ll know precisely the place they’re, and we’ll have heard from neighbours,” Staats mentioned. “Via the temporary-use course of, we notify neighbours, we put an advert within the paper, so if there is a social gathering home, council goes to find out about it earlier than they re-authorize it.”

City officers are hopeful the anticipated drop in residential visitor lodging might be precipitated by a rise in industrial tourism lodging.

“With that phase-out course of, we’re additionally going to be how we are able to facilitate or assist industrial visitor lodging, so motels, inns and people extra tourist-type rental lodging,” mentioned Staats.

Be taught extra about Gibsons’ method at

A wait-and-see method in Sydney

Over on Vancouver Island, officers in Sidney have taken a markedly extra cautious stance on short-term leases—for now.

In January, councillors there voted unanimously to remain the course on nightly leases, slightly than implement harder enforcement of the bylaw regulating short-term stays.

Because it stands, the bylaw permits short-term leases in most residential properties, offered it’s repeatedly occupied by a everlasting resident, be it the proprietor or a tenant. Like for many municipalities, nevertheless, enforcement of the bylaw is primarily complaint-based, and Sidney has struggled to get a deal with on how its housing provide is getting used. In response to a Saanich Information report, the general public heard earlier this 12 months that Sidney had but to concern a single superb towards a recognized operator of an unlawful nightly rental. Employees on the time famous the municipality doesn’t obtain many public complaints about short-term leases, and added that COVID-19 additional delayed enforcement.

Sidney’s council intends to revisit its enforcement method in 2023, and amidst issues from the lodge sector and a landmark courtroom ruling in Victoria that favors stricter enforcement, some officers consider it is solely a matter of time earlier than harder measures are launched.

Be taught extra about Sydney’s method at

Strict limits in Sechelt

One other Sunshine Coast group has lately rolled out new rules for trip leases, aimed toward preserving reasonably priced housing inventory for native renters.

In Sechelt, officers this month accepted a movement to cap the variety of secondary residences rented on a short-term foundation at 15. (CBC reported final week that the restrict applies to all trip leases, nevertheless it’s solely relevant to houses the place no main resident you reside.)

The district estimates there are roughly 50 such properties on the town, though Tourism Sunshine Coast places that quantity anyplace from 125 to 250 based mostly on info from AirDNA, a short-term rental knowledge platform.

“Thus far, now we have not really had something limiting any sort of short-term leases. In the event that they got here in and obtained a license, they have been allowed to function,” defined Sechelt Main Darnelda Siegers. “So now we have heard from people who find themselves constructing homes particularly for short-term leases, the non-owner-occupied ones, and
we are also having a lot of them on one block.”

The district’s regulatory technique can even help in higher understanding the scope of unlawful leases in the neighborhood, which has lengthy proved difficult.

“The way in which we’re qualifying it’s, if somebody has a principal residence however they’ve a separate outbuilding or suite or lodging separate from the first residence, once they really promote it on the platform, it’s a separate, complete unit. So we do not know if that is a home or if there’s a main proprietor with a separate suite,” Siegers defined. “We have been asking for extra particular info and it has been tough to get that.”

Siegers added that the seaside city is more likely to lose a phase of second owners, and Tourism Sunshine Coast’s government director, in a press release to CBC, additionally warned of the “widespread impression” dropping so many trip rental properties could have.

Siegers acknowledged the backlash from the tourism sector in addition to second owners, however mentioned finally the choice got here right down to a have to protect the group’s distinct character.

“Our concern is group match and the standard of life in a neighborhood when there are massive numbers of individuals coming in and residing beside you, rotating, and the impression of any person on trip—it impacts the standard of life,” she mentioned.

Be taught extra about Sechelt’s method at

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.