Skip to content

Metropolis of Tybee Island sued over short-term trip rental guidelines

TYBEE ISLAND, Ga. (WTOC) – A gaggle of residents, enterprise homeowners, realtors, and short-term trip rental managers, often known as the Tybee Alliance, are taking the Metropolis of Tybee Island to court docket.

They filed a lawsuit over the town’s dealing with of the short-term trip rental properties.

“We’re coping with a number of of us who need to flip a trip island into a personal island,” stated Dusty Church, a plaintiff and chair of the Tybee Alliance and the director of proprietor and enterprise improvement for Tybee Trip Leases.

“Sufficient is sufficient. We’ve got been making an attempt to barter and present as much as the conferences and be current in good religion and it looks like each time we present as much as the town council conferences we’re simply not heard,” stated Jenny Rutherford, a plaintiff and dealer with Jenny Rutherford Actual Property.

In August of 2021, the town enacted a moratorium on STVRs with a aim to strike a “steadiness” between residents’ high quality of life and rental properties.

What was initially anticipated to be a 90-day moratorium is now on its 14th month. It has been in place as the town works to jot down new STVR guidelines.

“It is so ambiguous we actually do not know what’s the aim,” stated Rutherford.

“The town has pushed for with, primarily, the identical factor they proposed six months in the past,” stated Church.

The Chair of Tybee Alliance, Dusty Church additionally works for Tybee Trip Leases. An organization that manages about 300 properties.

“We’re now compelled to behave within the courts.”

The lawsuit lists the town, mayor and all council members as defendants.

It reads that the town’s unique ordinance, put in place in 2016 to manage the usage of residential dwellings as short-term trip leases, is “invalid and unenforceable” as a result of the code sections aren’t according to Georgia legislation.

“State legislation prohibits rental properties from being required to be registered with a metropolis and the town of Tybee, as with many municipalities, has required that,” stated Church.

However Tybee’s ordinance says operators are required to register and acquire a separate license for every residential dwelling rental property it operates and it does not cease there.

Tybee Alliance members, like Steve Buckner say the brand new restrictions the town is now making an attempt to impose, like not permitting leases in residential zones and a requirement for properties to hire out for no less than 90 days of the yr to keep up STVR standing, is an “ assault” on peoples’ property rights.

“They’re trying to prohibit or take away licenses in our one the place we put the rental property. Our house can be required to hire for 90 days, which could not match our plan,” stated Buckner.

Like Buckner, many individuals say they personal an STVR to assist them pay to dwell on the island. Realtor and plaintiff, Jenny Rutherford says lots of patrons are afraid to speculate on Tybee now with out a clear understanding of what is going on to occur subsequent.

“It looks like that this ordinance was put collectively by individuals who need to have the ability to select their neighbors,” stated Rutherford.

They usually really feel like all properties ought to have the identical proper to hire no matter the place it is positioned or what number of days it is rented for.

“When you’ve got an issue with parking and trash and noise then implement it. They’re making an attempt to place a cap on who can and who cannot have registrations and that is not acceptable. There’s simply no strategy to implement it legally,” stated Keith Homosexual, a plaintiff and proprietor of Tybee Seaside Trip Leases.

Church additionally says there are extra fulltime residents on the island than ever earlier than and if the town is making an attempt to get much more everlasting residents.

“Trip leases are a serious feeder for people to turn out to be fulltime residents via eventual retirement into their rental properties,” stated Church.

The council could have the second studying of the proposed ordinance on Thursday, which suggests the moratorium may come to an finish.

“In the event that they cross the second studying on Thursday we’ll merely amend our grievance to incorporate the extra violations of legislation that the town council has handed,” stated Church.

We reached out to the town for a press release. They stated:

The Metropolis of Tybee Island has no touch upon pending litigation or upcoming metropolis council conferences the place STRs could also be mentioned.

The assembly is on Thursday at 6:30 on the public security constructing.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *